Choosing the right server for your business is not a technical but rather strategic decision. It can be the make-or-break point, especially for any high-traffic or resource-intensive website. And if that is the kind of hosting solution you need, you might be weighing up the choice between a bare metal vs dedicated server.
It's a tricky decision to make. Part of this is because many hosts often throw around the terms 'bare metal' and 'dedicated server' and even use them interchangeably. This conflation may leave you wondering which web hosting solution between these two is right for your business or application.
It is not a trivial decision. Get it wrong, and you could face some serious repercussions.
For instance, bare metal hosting and dedicated servers are not cheap. Therefore, you'll want to get good value for your money. Also, the wrong choice will lead to inefficiencies. You may end up with more maintenance tasks than expected or perhaps pay for managed services you don't need.
Being locked in a long-term plan could make these mistakes even costlier. But, with a bit of insight, they are avoidable.
With that in mind, this post will compare bare metal vs dedicated servers to give you the insights needed to choose the right option for your business. So, let's begin by defining what these servers are.
What is a Bare Metal Server?
For starters, a bare metal is pretty much like a dedicated server. It's one physical machine leased or rented to a single client, organization, or business entity. But what sets it apart is that it will come with no hypervisor or software stack on top.
This lack of intermediary layers or virtualization is where 'bare metals' get their name. The idea is that users get the server in its purest form—raw hardware with the highest level of control and customization.
As such, you can fine-tune server configurations without any virtualization or provider-imposed constraints. For instance, you can allocate all hardware resources directly to workloads without overhead from a hypervisor. You will also have greater flexibility in implementing custom monitoring and logging solutions, as you're not limited to the predefined tools and data access restrictions of a managed dedicated host.
Stripped to its core, bare metal servers typically only come with hardware management interfaces such as IMPI or iLO. These tools facilitate remote management tasks like rebooting, monitoring hardware health, and installing OS images.
Some hosts may give you the option to have the bare metal provisioned with an OS and control panel. But beyond the initial server setup, there would typically be no more ongoing maintenance.
If you prefer to start on a clean slate, you will have the ability to install any operating system, hypervisor, or desired programs after provisioning a bare metal server rental since it offers full administrative/root access. However, these types of servers are usually user-administered. That means you'll be responsible for managing the machine. So, installing updates, running backups, and taking other steps to keep the server secure and running well requires true system administrator abilities.
What is a Dedicated Server?
Similarly, dedicated servers offer exclusive control of all the resources a physical machine provides but with a slightly different focus. While still single-tenant servers, they often operate within a managed ecosystem offered by hosting companies that include additional layers of support, security, and services as part of the package. In other words, a managed dedicated server would typically come with pre-installed software or configurations, making it less 'bare' and more ready to use.
The term 'dedicated' highlights there's no sharing of server resources with other users. Because of this isolation, you get unrivaled performance, security, and control compared to alternative types of web hosting.
Bare Metal vs Dedicated Server: How Do They Differ?
So, how does a bare metal vs dedicated server differ? If you have followed through to this point, you may have noticed one main difference.
As we've established, both offer exclusive single-tenant physical hardware. However, the key difference lies in the level of pre-configured software and management the hosting company provides. This distinction isn't just a matter of terminology. It's a factor that affects setup time, management responsibilities, flexibility, and even the best use cases. Let's break these down one by one.
1 Provisioning Time
Since bare metal servers come with minimal pre-installed software, they are typically faster to provision. With little to no configuring beyond hardware initialization, they are ready for customization right after setup. So this makes them ideal for users who want total control from the start.
On the other hand, dedicated servers may take longer to provision. Many come pre-installed with operating systems, control panels, and security tools. These pre-configurations, while beneficial for some, adds to the initial setup time.
However, some hosting providers allow users to select configurations during checkout, such as an optional OS or control panel. Such presets trigger scripts or workflows that automate the process. This automation makes provisioning faster than it would be if everything were configured manually by the hosting team.
Ultimately, the exact provisioning time depends on the provider and chosen specifications. Automated workflows help speed up the process, but more complex configurations may still take longer.
2 Cost Implications
When comparing a bare metal vs dedicated server, cost is a key factor as well. So, how do both compare?
Bare metal servers often have a lower initial cost due to the fact that you're primarily paying for the hardware itself. But remember, you're responsible for software licensing, operating system costs, and ongoing maintenance.
On the other hand, dedicated hosting typically comes with a higher upfront cost. This price includes the hardware, pre-installed software, and some level of management or maintenance support. It may seem more expensive initially. However, it can be more cost-effective in the long run for those who prefer convenience.
It is essential, though, to consider the total cost of ownership (TCO). You should factor in server management time, software expenses, and potential downtime. A seemingly cheaper bare metal server could become more expensive if you need to hire system administrators to manage it.
With that in mind, consider your team's expertise and how much control you need. If you have dedicated IT staff, bare metal might be more cost-effective. If you prefer a hands-off approach to maintenance, a dedicated server with managed services might be the better choice. Assess your specific needs and budget to make the best decision.
3 Server Management
So, how does a bare metal vs dedicated server stack up when it comes to server management?
Since bare metal servers are unmanaged, you'll have to handle everything from updates and security patches to performance optimizations and other administrative tasks. It's a more hands-on web hosting option. As such, bare metal hosting would be ideal for businesses that either have or can afford to hire in-house IT staff or for situations where complete control over server management is a priority.
On the other hand, dedicated servers, especially those with managed hosting, reduce the workload. Depending on the host, you won't have to worry about tasks like system updates, monitoring, or ongoing maintenance. It's the ideal choice if you want to free up your time to focus more on deploying and running your application.
4 Control & Flexibility
Another key difference that emerges when comparing bare metal vs dedicated servers is the level of control you get.
A bare metal server gives you full customization from scratch. For instance, you can install a custom OS, run a non-standard database, configure advanced firewall rules, etc. The level of flexibility is just unmatched.
As with bare metal hosting, a dedicated server also offers full administrative or root access. But, if managed services are part of the package, there might be restrictions on some configurations or software installations set by the provider. Therefore, make sure to read the terms to avoid inconveniences.
The choice between bare metal vs dedicated server may come down to how much control you need. If your workload demands a fully customized environment, bare metal might be a better option. Alternatively, a dedicated server could be more suitable if you prefer a balance of ease of use and control.
5 Bare Metal vs Dedicated Servers Use Cases
When deciding between a bare metal vs dedicated server, taking into account the nature of your specific use cases can help guide your choice. Both options provide dedicated resources but cater to different needs based on control, customization, and management.
1. Bare Metal Server Use Cases
Bare metal servers are ideal when you require complete control over your hardware and software configurations. They usually come in handy in scenarios where performance and customization are critical. Some examples where they come in handy include:
- Custom Enterprise Applications: Businesses developing resource-intensive, custom applications benefit from the unfettered control a bare metal offers. For example, large databases or high-performance computing tasks demand hardware fine-tuned to specific needs.
- High-Performance Computing (HPC): Research institutions running simulations or machine learning workloads require raw processing power. Bare metal ensures no virtualization overhead, maximizing performance for computationally heavy tasks.
- Specialized OS or Kernel Customization: If you need to build or modify a custom kernel, bare metal servers allow you to make these adjustments directly, such as for gaming servers or specialized firewall configurations.
- Heavy Workloads with Full Control: Projects like video rendering farms or financial institutions with real-time risk analysis require maximum hardware efficiency, and bare metal servers provide just that.
2. Dedicated Server Use Cases
On the other hand, dedicated servers are great for businesses that want dedicated hardware but prefer to offload some management complexity. While they also offer powerful performance, they come with tools that simplify server maintenance. Some scenarios where a dedicated server is ideal include:
- Mission-Critical Web Hosting: Businesses running essential websites or applications—such as financial platforms or healthcare portals—use dedicated servers for guaranteed uptime, security, and performance. Managed services help ensure smooth operation with proactive monitoring, backups, and security updates.
- E-Commerce Platforms: An e-commerce business with high traffic might prefer a dedicated server to have control over server resources while using management tools to ensure uptime, updates, and security without the technical complexity of a bare metal setup.
- Gaming Servers: Game developers or providers hosting multiplayer servers often choose dedicated hosting. The pre-configured management tools streamline mod installations and server settings, offering a good balance of control and convenience.
- Managed Databases: Companies running large databases can opt for dedicated servers too, which provide the power needed while simplifying maintenance through management features like automated backups and updates.
In short, bare metal servers shine in use cases that demand high customization, non-standard configurations, raw computing power, and complete control over the hardware.
On the other hand, dedicated servers offer a balance of performance and ease of use, with added management tools to simplify server tasks and maintenance.
Ultimately, your decision depends on whether you need absolute flexibility or a more streamlined approach.
Table Comparison
| Feature | Bare Metal Server | Dedicated Server |
|---|---|---|
| Virtualization | No virtualization by default (raw hardware access) | May include virtualization for easier management |
| Provisioning Time | Faster (due to minimal pre-installed software) | May take longer (due to pre-installed OS, control panel, security tools) |
| Cost | Lower upfront, but requires in-house management | Higher upfront, but includes management support |
| Server Management | Unmanaged (User responsible for maintenance) | Managed options available (less admin work) |
| Control & Flexibility | Maximum customization – install any OS, configure non-standard setups | Some restrictions with managed services, but still offers administrative/root access |
| Use Cases | High-performance computing, custom enterprise apps, specialized OS/kernel modifications, heavy workloads | Web hosting, e-commerce platforms, gaming servers, managed databases |
Over to You
As we have established, choosing between a bare metal vs dedicated server requires careful consideration. That's because these two hosting solutions carry subtle but important distinctions that can influence the ideal choice for your IT infrastructure.
While both options offer maximum performance, each has its advantages and disadvantages. Those added benefits or applicable drawbacks will ultimately make the decision for you.
In summary, bare metal offers the highest level of customization. This server type gives you granular control of everything you want to do, making it ideal for technically proficient teams with demanding workloads. Conversely, dedicated servers provide a balance of performance and simplicity by taking away some of the complexity that comes with managing a bare metal. But this simplicity comes with a loss of control or ability to tinker with each of those individual server settings.
So, the tipping point really is, how much control do you want, how much are you willing to give up, or how much simplicity do you want? Therefore, carefully weigh your technical expertise, budget, and performance needs to make the best choice for your business.
Ready to make the right decision for your business?
Book Free Consultation!
Our team of experts can help you determine whether a bare metal vs dedicated server is the best fit for your specific needs and set it up for you. Contact us today for a free consultation, and let us help you optimize your infrastructure for success..
